At first I tested the WMP only and it worked pretty well. I did not have to consider putting external pullup resistors or desoldering internal pullups as it worked out of the box.
But I encountered serious problems with the NC connected in passthrough mode.
Sometimes I get I2C errors rising like hell and then there is this kind of strange 'reset' of the I2C every few seconds and the NC not working at all.
Currently I use 2K resistance from 3.3V to pullup the lines, but it does not work. At 5V the same error occurs.
Any help is appreciated

Thanks

Image of the setup
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wLYKQNz_-XY
Video of the MultiWiiConfig